How to turn an outdated Christmas decoration into beautiful, vintage-inspired holiday décor. Get ready for my Pottery Barn snowman look for less using a thrift store find!
I found the cutest little snowman at the thrift store. Well, maybe not exactly cute in his original condition! He had a bright red scarf, a shiny black hat, and that traditional Christmas look that just wasn’t quite my style.
But I loved his shape, and I knew he had potential.
After having so much fun transforming thrifted pumpkins into Pottery Barn-inspired pottery this fall, I started wondering if I could use that exact same technique on a Christmas decoration.
And guess what? It worked!
With a brown paper bag, Mod Podge, a few of my favorite paint colors, and a little sanding, I transformed my colorful thrifted snowman into a beautiful, aged pottery piece.
I love how he turned out, and I think you’ll be surprised at how easy this makeover is!

The Inspiration Behind My Pottery Barn Snowman Look For Less
I’ve always loved Christmas decorations that feel timeless and collected rather than overly bright or trendy.
Give me natural textures, muted colors, vintage-inspired finishes, and pieces that look like they’ve been around for years.
That’s exactly the look I wanted for this little snowman.
Instead of his original red, white, and black finish, I envisioned something that resembled aged pottery, with soft neutral colors, imperfect texture, and subtle painted details.
I wanted him to blend beautifully with the other pieces in our home while still feeling festive for Christmas.
And the best part? I didn’t need to purchase an expensive new decoration to get the look.
I just needed to see the potential in something someone else had donated.
Here is what he looked like before.

Supplies for This Pottery Barn Snowman Look For Less
If you read my original pumpkin makeover tutorial, you’ll recognize these supplies!
I used the same materials and paint colors to create this aged pottery finish.
Here’s what you’ll need:
- A thrifted snowman decoration
- A brown paper grocery bag
- Matte Mod Podge
- Foam brush
- FolkArt Matte Acrylic Paint in Raw Umber
- FolkArt Matte Acrylic Paint in Barnwood
- FolkArt Matte Acrylic Paint in Concrete
- FolkArt Matte Acrylic Paint in Mushroom
- Small paintbrushes
- Painter’s tape in varying widths
- Sanding block or fine-grit sandpaper
- Scissors, optional
I love that most of these supplies are inexpensive, and you may already have several of them in your craft supplies.
Step 1: Find a Snowman with Potential
The first step is finding a snowman to transform.
Mine was a traditional little snowman with a black top hat, red scarf, and smiling face.
He was cute, but definitely not the look I was going for.
When shopping for thrifted Christmas decorations, I try to look past the colors and focus on the overall shape.
This snowman had a great silhouette, and I knew the raised details would add character once I covered him with texture and paint.
Don’t worry if your snowman has an outdated finish. That’s what makes this project so fun!
Just make sure the piece is clean, dry, and sturdy before getting started.

Step 2: Add Texture with Brown Paper and Mod Podge
This is where the transformation begins!
I used the same brown paper technique from my thrifted pumpkin project to create the appearance of aged pottery.
Start by tearing a brown paper grocery bag into small, irregular pieces.
Using a foam brush, apply a thin layer of Matte Mod Podge to a section of the snowman.
Press a piece of brown paper onto the surface and brush another thin layer of Mod Podge over the top.
Continue working around the snowman, overlapping the pieces of paper until the surface is covered.
Don’t worry about making everything perfectly smooth.
The wrinkles, overlaps, and little imperfections are exactly what give the finished piece its beautiful handmade texture.
Work carefully around the hat, scarf, and other raised details so you don’t lose the snowman’s shape.
Once everything is covered, allow it to dry completely.
My tip: Don’t try to make the paper too perfect! Those imperfections are what make the finished snowman look like aged pottery rather than a freshly painted Christmas decoration.
Step 3: Paint Your Pottery Barn Snowman Look For Less
Once the Mod Podge is dry, it’s time to paint!
I used the same FolkArt Matte acrylic paint colors from my Pottery Barn pumpkin makeover.
I started with Raw Umber as the base color.
This deep brown creates a beautiful foundation for the aged pottery look.
Apply the paint over the paper-covered snowman, working it into the texture and around the raised details.
Allow the first coat to dry and add another coat wherever you need more coverage.
Next, I used Barnwood and Concrete to create dimension.
Using a dry-brush technique, lightly brush these colors over the raised areas.
The trick is to use very little paint.
You want some of that darker Raw Umber to remain visible underneath so the finish has depth and looks naturally aged.
I love how these colors work together to create a soft, weathered appearance.
Step 4: Add the Vintage-Inspired Stripes
This is one of my favorite details!
I loved the striped look on my original Pottery Barn-inspired pumpkins, so I decided to incorporate that same detail into my snowman.
For the lighter stripes, I used FolkArt Matte Acrylic Paint in Mushroom.
You can use painter’s tape to create stripes in varying widths.
On a textured surface, I like to seal the tape edges with a little Matte Mod Podge before painting. This helps prevent paint from bleeding underneath.
Once the Mod Podge is dry, paint your stripes using Mushroom.
I love how the soft, creamy color contrasts with the darker aged finish.
And don’t worry if your stripes aren’t absolutely perfect.
A slightly worn, handmade appearance is exactly what we’re going for!
Step 5: Distress Your Pottery Barn Snowman Dupe
Now for the finishing touch that really brings everything together!
Once all the paint has dried, take a sanding block or fine-grit sandpaper and gently sand over the surface.
You don’t need to sand heavily.
Just lightly catch the raised areas, edges, and textured details.
This softens the paint and helps create that beautiful timeworn appearance.
The sanding also allows some of the darker layers to show through, which makes the finish look much more natural.
I think this is one of the most important steps in getting that aged pottery look.
Suddenly, that bright little thrift store snowman looks like a completely different piece!
The Finished Pottery Barn Snowman Dupe
I am so happy with how this little guy turned out!
What started as a traditional red-and-white Christmas decoration now has the appearance of an old, handcrafted pottery piece.
I love the muted colors, the imperfect texture, and the soft stripes.
He feels so much more timeless now and fits beautifully with the collected, neutral décor I love using in our home.
And I especially love knowing that I gave something old a completely new life.
That’s the magic of a good thrift store makeover!

Love This Look? Try My Pottery Barn Pumpkin Dupe Too!
If this technique looks familiar, that’s because I originally used it to transform thrifted pumpkins into beautiful, aged pottery-inspired fall decorations.
You can see that entire makeover in my Pottery Barn Pumpkin Dupe Using Thrifted Pumpkins tutorial.
I used the same brown paper, Mod Podge, paint colors, and distressing technique for both projects.
I love finding a method that works so well I can use it for different seasons!
It’s also a wonderful reminder to look at thrift store decorations with a little imagination.
You never know what something could become.
Sharing Christmas Inspiration with Annie from Most Lovely Things
I’m also excited because my friend Annie from Most Lovely Things and I are both sharing Christmas projects!
I always love seeing what Annie creates. She has such a beautiful eye for decorating and finding creative ways to make a home feel special.
If you’re looking for even more holiday inspiration, be sure to head over to her blog and see what she’s sharing.
Visit Annie at Most Lovely Things
It’s always more fun to share a little creativity with friends, especially during the holidays!
Love This Pottery Barn Snowman Dupe? Pin It for Later!
If you love budget-friendly Christmas decorating and thrift store makeovers, be sure to save this project to Pinterest!
You never know when you’ll come across an outdated snowman at the thrift store, and this is such a fun way to give one a completely new look.
PIN IT FOR LATER!
Save this Pottery Barn Snowman Dupe tutorial to your Christmas DIY, Thrift Store Makeovers, or Vintage Christmas Décor Pinterest board so you can easily find it when you’re ready to make your own.
And if you try this project, I’d love to see how yours turns out!

More Thrifting Inspiration: Trash to Treasure
If you love transforming thrift store finds into beautiful pieces for your home, be sure to check out my e-book, Trash to Treasure!
It’s filled with inspiration for finding, transforming, and styling secondhand treasures.
I truly believe you don’t need to spend a fortune to create a beautiful home. Sometimes you just need a little imagination and a willingness to look beyond what something is right now.
Shop My Trash to Treasure E-Book
Happy thrifting, and happy Christmas decorating!
Shop This Pottery Barn Snowman Dupe Project
Want to recreate this aged pottery finish? Here are the supplies and paint colors used for the project.
Matte Mod Podge
I used Matte Mod Podge to attach the brown paper and create the textured surface.
FolkArt Matte Acrylic Paint in Raw Umber
This deep brown creates the base for the aged pottery finish.
FolkArt Matte Acrylic Paint in Barnwood
I used this color to add subtle highlights and dimension.
FolkArt Matte Acrylic Paint in Concrete
This is another beautiful neutral shade for creating that weathered pottery appearance.
FolkArt Matte Acrylic Paint in Mushroom
I used this soft, creamy color for the decorative stripes.
Additional Supplies
- Foam Brushes
- Painter’s Tape
- Sanding Blocks
- Brown paper grocery bag
- Thrifted snowman decoration
Shop My Sweet Savannah
Looking for more affordable decorating ideas, favorite finds, and seasonal inspiration?
Shop My Trash to Treasure E-Book
This post contains affiliate shopping links. I may earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting My Sweet Savannah!



Leave a Reply